Chapter 5
Dr. Laurie W. Rush
“So You Believe in Aliens Too?”
An Anthropologist Looks at Stone Features in the North American Northeast and the Archaeologists Who Do and Do Not Study Them
https://uapress.arizona.edu/book/our-hidden-landscapes
“No, I do not believe
in aliens, nor do I believe that the people who inhabited the northeastern
United States for more than 10,000 years never built anything out of stone.' It
is equally incredible to me that farmers of European origin who only inhabited this
same landscape for fewer than 500 years could be responsible for the
construction of every single stone structure we encounter in the region today.
What I also find hard to believe is how many archaeologists in the 21st century
fail to apply robust scientific methodology to the analysis of stone features
encountered every day in the landscapes of our region. This failure and the
associated emotional responses to serious attempts at scientific discourse on
the stone landscape issue beg for anthropological and historical analyses of
the causes of this phenomenon, along with solutions for approaching more
objective research in the future.”
There are stone cultural features found throughout the
landscapes of northeastern North America, and most archaeologists agree that
these structures were created by people in the past. The controversy emerges
when a new generation of archaeologists and people initiate objective research
designed to conclusively determine the ancestry of these features. To accurately
understand the true origins of the stone features of the Northeast,
archaeologists of northeastern North America need to:
Our Hidden Landscapes
Indigenous Stone
Ceremonial Sites in Eastern North America
Lucianne Lavin (Editor), Elaine Thomas (Editor)
Foreword by Laurie Weinstein
Introduction by Lucianne Lavin and Elaine Thomas
Part I. Indigenous Perspectives on the Meaning and Significance of Ceremonial Stone Landscapes
1. When the Landscape Speaks for Itself, What Do We Learn? by
Doug Harris
2. Markings of Ancestral Pathways: A Native Perspective by Elaine
Thomas
3. Unseen Borders and Ways of Knowing: Northeastern
Algonquian Sacred Lands by Nohham Rolf Cachat-Schilling
Part II. Academic Perspectives on Understanding, Protecting,
and Preserving Indigenous Ceremonial Stone Landscapes
4. Obligations of Place: Engaging with Tribal Historic
Preservation Offices in New England to Preserve and Protect Ceremonial Stone
Landscapes by Paul A. Robinson
5. “So You Believe in Aliens, Too?” An Anthropologist Looks
at Stone Features in the North American Northeast and the Archaeologists Who Do
and Do Not Study Them by Laurie W. Rush
6. Introduction to Stone Removal and Disposal Practices in
Agriculture and Farming by James E. Gage
7. Ceremonial Landscapes in the Chesapeake by Julia A. King
and Scott M. Strickland
8. Stones and Their Places: An Application of Landscape
Theory to Ceremonial Stone Landscapes of West Virginia by Matthew Victor Weiss
and Charity Moore Norton
9. Piled Stone Features of Jackson County, Georgia by Johannes
H. N. Loubser
Part III. Case Studies of Ceremonial Stone Landscapes
10. A Sacred Space on a Hilltop in Harwinton, Connecticut by
Robert DeFosses
11. Interpreting Row-Linked Boulder Sites from Georgia to
New England by Norman Muller
12. Historic Ceremonial Structures by Mary Gage
13. A Theoretical Model of the Moon and the Milky Way at
Ancient Meeting Places by Frederick W. Martin
14. Mythologies of Light and Cast Shadow Within Northeastern
Stone Chambers by Kathleen Patricia Thrane
Nohham Rolf Cachat-Schilling
Robert DeFosses
James Gage
Mary Gage
Doug Harris
Julia A. King
Lucianne Lavin
Johannes (Jannie) H. N. Loubser
Frederick W. Martin
Norman Muller
Charity Moore Norton
Paul A. Robinson
Laurie W. Rush
Scott M. Strickland
Elaine Thomas
Kathleen Patricia Thrane
Matthew Victor Weiss
Thank You, Mr. Tim MacSweeney for this writing and commentary today. Because You're asking the right question; "This failure and the associated emotional responses to serious attempts at scientific discourse on the stone landscape issue beg for anthropological and historical analyses of the causes of this phenomenon, along with solutions for approaching more objective research in the future.” I want to know why.
ReplyDeleteJerry: I'm just quoting Dr. Rush, an excerpt from the book where she elaborates further...
Delete